5 Signs of a Failing HR Department


Table of Contents

What the hell is HR doing? Have you ever asked yourself that at work? Do you trust your HR department, or are you a logical philosopher and you think HR pretends to be your friend but will stab you in the back in the interest of the company? HR is definitely or at least it definitely should be a hot topic at the office.

A well-run HR department can make a huge, positive difference to your business. Legal problems can be avoided, finances can be improved, employees can feel comfortable and productive, and valued for their work. Customers and clients will notice the effects of a business with a strong culture of excellence. However, not all HR departments are as effective as they should be.

Today we’re looking at the top 5 symptoms of a failing HR department and their significance to the success of the company.

failing hr department

Lack of Employee Engagement

Statistics show that 86% of the problems in the enterprise are caused by the lack of effective collaboration and communication. Communication is the higher level of management, and many business management problems are mostly caused by insufficient communication.

Employee engagement is a critical factor in the success of any organization. Engaged employees are more committed to their work, more productive, and more likely to stay with the company long-term. However, a failing HR department can have a significant negative impact on employee engagement.

A failing HR department can negatively affect employee engagement in several ways. One common issue is a lack of communication and transparency. When employees feel that they are not kept in the loop about company news or changes, they may feel disconnected from the organization. Similarly, a lack of recognition and appreciation can also contribute to disengagement. When employees feel that their contributions are not valued, they may become less motivated and less invested in their work.

To measure employee engagement, HR departments can use a variety of tools and techniques. One popular method is the employee engagement survey. This survey typically includes questions about job satisfaction, motivation, communication, and other factors that can affect engagement. By analyzing the results of the survey, HR departments can identify areas of weakness and develop strategies to improve engagement.

Another way to measure employee engagement is through regular feedback and performance reviews. By providing regular feedback and setting clear expectations, managers can help employees feel more connected to their work and the organization. Additionally, HR departments can track metrics such as absenteeism, turnover rates, and productivity to get a sense of overall engagement levels.

To improve employee engagement in a failing HR department, several strategies can be implemented. For example, HR departments can focus on improving communication and transparency by providing regular updates and soliciting feedback from employees. Recognition and appreciation programs can also be implemented to help employees feel valued and motivated. Additionally, offering opportunities for professional development and growth can help employees feel more invested in their work and the organization.

High employee turnover

Whether it’s because of employees being fired or choosing to leave the company for another job, a high turnover rate falls under the symptoms of a bad HR department. If many employees are fired or replaced then the hiring or onboarding process is flawed. If many employees leave the company for other jobs then the work atmosphere, compensation, or reward structures are flawed. After all, the key responsibilities of HR are to attract and retain good talents.

According to The American Society for Human Resource Management, the cost of replacing a highly educated executive is 213% of his or her annual salary. Turnover is often higher at the lower levels of the pyramid and less likely to be taken seriously by executives, but it is just as costly to the organization and less easy for executives to find a cure. Every “skilled worker” turnover in an organization should not be underestimated.

While employees are more likely to leave bad managers than bad jobs, an effective HR department allows managers to do a good job of direct reporting. As employees leave one after another, it is HR’s job to investigate what may have caused the employee to leave – whether it was poor management, unreasonable pay, and benefits, a hostile work environment, or any other reason.

These investigations must be conducted ethically and must address any legal issues related to harassment or unfair treatment. If the HR department fails to find the root causes of high turnover rates and is unable to effectively address issues, it may decrease employees’ sense of belonging and passion. 

failing hr department

Poor Hiring Decisions

Making good hiring decisions is crucial for the success of any organization. A company’s employees are its most valuable asset, and it is essential to find the right people to fill open positions. Poor hiring decisions can have serious consequences, including reduced productivity, increased turnover, and damage to the organization’s reputation.

A failing HR department can make poor hiring decisions for several reasons. One common problem is a lack of clear job descriptions and candidate criteria. Without a clear understanding of what the job entails, HR may struggle to identify the right candidates for the role. In addition, a lack of effective screening processes can also lead to poor hiring decisions. Rushing to fill a position or relying too heavily on resumes can result in candidates who do not have the necessary skills or experience.

To improve hiring decisions, HR departments can implement several strategies. One key step is to establish clear job descriptions and candidate criteria for each position. This will help HR identify the right candidates and avoid wasting time on applicants who are not a good fit. Additionally, HR can use a variety of screening methods, such as phone interviews, assessments, and reference checks, to ensure that candidates meet the necessary qualifications.

Another effective strategy is to involve multiple stakeholders in the hiring process. This can include managers, team members, and even external experts who can provide valuable insights into the role and the candidates. A diverse range of perspectives can help identify potential red flags or strengths in candidates that may not be immediately apparent.

Finally, HR departments can also consider implementing technology solutions to improve hiring decisions. Applicant tracking systems, for example, can help automate the screening process and reduce bias in candidate selection. Artificial intelligence tools can also be used to analyze resumes and identify key qualifications, skills, and experience.

In conclusion, making good hiring decisions is essential for the success of any organization. A failing HR department can make poor hiring decisions, but there are strategies that can be implemented to improve the process. By establishing clear job descriptions, using effective screening methods, involving multiple stakeholders, and leveraging technology, HR departments can ensure that they hire the right people for the job.

failing hr

Inefficient HR Processes

Efficient HR processes are essential for the smooth functioning of an organization. HR departments are responsible for managing a wide range of activities, including recruitment, onboarding, training, performance management, and employee relations. Inefficient processes can lead to wasted time, increased costs, and a lack of productivity.

A failing HR department can have inefficient processes for several reasons. One common problem is a lack of standardization and consistency in processes. If each HR professional follows a different set of procedures, it can be difficult to track progress and identify areas for improvement. Additionally, a lack of automation can also lead to inefficiencies. Manual processes, such as filing and data entry, can be time-consuming and error-prone, which can slow down the HR process.

To streamline HR processes, HR departments can implement several strategies. One key step is to establish clear standard operating procedures (SOPs) for each HR activity. SOPs can help ensure that each HR professional follows the same process, which can improve consistency and reduce errors. Additionally, HR departments can automate many processes using technology solutions, such as HR information systems (HRIS) or applicant tracking systems (ATS). Automation can save time and reduce errors, which can improve efficiency.

Another effective strategy is to leverage data to identify areas for improvement. HR departments can use metrics, such as time to fill positions or turnover rates, to identify areas where processes may be inefficient. For example, if it takes an unusually long time to fill a position, it may be necessary to review the recruitment process to identify bottlenecks.

Lack of Compliance with Employment Laws

Complying with employment laws is critical for any organization. Employment laws are designed to protect employees’ rights and ensure fair and equitable treatment in the workplace. Failure to comply with these laws can result in legal action, fines, and damage to the organization’s reputation.

A failing HR department can fail to comply with employment laws for several reasons. One common problem is a lack of knowledge about the relevant laws and regulations. Without a clear understanding of the legal requirements, HR may inadvertently violate employment laws, leading to legal consequences.

A lack of proper record-keeping can also lead to compliance issues. HR departments must maintain accurate records of employee information, including hours worked, wages paid, and benefits provided. Failure to keep these records up to date can lead to compliance issues and legal challenges.

To ensure compliance with employment laws, organizations can take several steps. One key strategy is to invest in ongoing training for HR staff on relevant laws and regulations. This will ensure that HR is up to date on the latest requirements and best practices for compliance.

Additionally, organizations can implement strong record-keeping and documentation processes. HR departments should establish clear guidelines for record-keeping and regularly audit their records to ensure they are accurate and up to date.

Another strategy is to work with external legal counsel to ensure compliance with employment laws. Legal experts can provide valuable guidance on compliance issues and help organizations develop effective policies and procedures.

Finally, organizations can consider implementing technology solutions to support compliance efforts. For example, HR software can help automate record-keeping and ensure that employee information is accurate and up to date.

hr department


Our bilingual legal and HR team takes care of your employment compliance in China so that you can focus on your business growth. Whether or not you have an entity in China, we have fully compliant and cost-effective solutions to manage your HR. We provide professional HR services in China, including but not limited to payroll, tax, benefits, and recruitment.

Scroll to Top